Chuunin Exams- Island D

[hotaru]

Name: Hotaru
Age: 18
Gender: Female
Type of Complaint: Unfairness
Insident Link: Chuunin Exams - Group D
Complaint:

During our thread, there came a point in which Yami and Takeshi both ignored a jutsu I had used because the jutsu used by Takeshi (they thought) was enough to destroy our clones and allow them safe passage into the dome. Because the dome has a metal floor, the jutsu used would have no effect on myself, my partner, or the clones (contrary to the decision of the CE that metal can be turned into mud), meaning that we were unhindered in our attempt at attacking them.

I discussed this with our Chuunin Examiner who gave me the go ahead for my critical hit to break their chain. (Without this confirmation, I never would have tried to disqualify them and simply gone for a fatality). After I posted my critical hit approved by the CE, he posted and took it back, saying he would give our opponents the chance to counter.

After an attempted dodge, I do not believe that Takeshi would have had ample time to remove an exploding tag and detonate it on the needles without damaging himself or his partner and still have time to construct a wall of stone to defend from my partners Water Dragon Whip jutsu. I also do not believe that Tree Binding Death (the jutsu used by Yami) is able to target 20 people at one time.

Solution:

A battle moderator read over the incident in question and make an appropriate ruling, and for an over all better effort by the examiners. This is a big event guys, step it up =\

[Kuro]

Why make a complaint? Really? Just PM other Examiners to take a look at it. We said the same thing to the Complaints earlier about the chuunin exams.

[👺 Usiel]

Hell, you are staff, why not talk to the people?

[tetsu]

Apr 12, 2009 12:44:32 GMT -7 👺 Usiel said:

Hell, you are staff, why not talk to the people?

Because she's a contestant and as such, she can't use her position of authority over people because that would be against the rules? Also, as staff, she's not allowed to mediate any instance where she's personally involved?

As to why make a complaint, considering that the complaints section has been primarily used as a place for staff to vent their frustration at the members instead of having it's real purpose, that of handling complaints, I find it interesting that when there's an actual complaint being posted, people are told to take it to PMs or it's simply ignored. What's the point of having the complaints board in the first place? Just change the name to "Place Where Staff Can Bitch At Members Without Getting In Trouble" and call it at that, please.

Otherwise, she has a legit complaint, and guess what? This is the place to handle complaints. The CE are just as much a part of the site as anything else, and they can be handled here.

[👺 Usiel]

Well, I haven't posted in here or bitched in here in months. And well as Staff members they are supposed to communicate with one another in a closer fashion in which she can or could have stated it without bringing it completely out. Also as a staff member she never spoke to a Headmod or me dealing with this complaint. You see, the Complaint's board is like last resort, she didn't go through the chain of command. I might not be in charge of the exams but if something is really wrong I don't mind stepping in. Now then Lash, you are not staff, Complaints are for them so please kindly do not post in Complaints. However you do bring in some valid points so Hotaru I will ask

I discussed this with our Chuunin Examiner who gave me the go ahead for my critical hit to break their chain. (Without this confirmation, I never would have tried to disqualify them and simply gone for a fatality). After I posted my critical hit approved by the CE, he posted and took it back, saying he would give our opponents the chance to counter.

Please send me the PMs or information in which the CE has said this. Also please tell me (Through PMs) as to which Chuunin Examiner has done this as well. Also, I ask where did the conversation with the CE happen. I pray not over MSN or YIM.

[👺 Usiel]

Double Post: Before I forget, if Genbu is not in there I want him to be the Battle Mod to check it out.

[seppuku]

Edit: Posted my decision and reasons for such. Takeshi and Arashi have been eliminated.

[hotaru]

K thank you, this can be locked now ^-^

[Elgar]

Locked